



So you know when you first hear that a band has come out with a new album. You purchase/download the album, play it through for the first time, and afterward you either love it or hate it, right? WRONG! Music is not that simple. But don't worry, I think I've figured out. You see, albums can be broken down into 5 unique categories of quality. These categories are based solely upon how that new album stacks up to other albums within that same artist/band's discography, because after all, each band has its own unique sound, and comparing albums across bands is like comparing apples and oranges (although I will attempt to do this anyways when I give you my list of "Top Albums of the 2000s" later this year). So here they are, my five categories, ranging from the best to progressively worse.
1) The Revelation: This is the album, that when you hear it, it's like you've had some type of miraculous religious experience. In relation to the band's previous work, The Revelation makes those albums seem amateurish and insignificant. It's like looking back at those pictures you have of yourself all pimply-faced and wearing braces back in the sixth grade, when you just want to tell that person in the picture to just wait, things will get better, oh yes, they will get better. This is what The Revelation is, it's that rare album in which a band makes a quantum leap to another level of greatness, a level that's so great, in fact, that you find it nearly impossible to listen to any of their earlier works.
Example: LCD Soundsystem- Sound of Silver
2) The Caffeine Pill: This album, much like the revelation, knocks you off your feet right from the get go. You forget about the rest of the band's albums, and find yourself listening to this album solely for weeks. But, unlike the revelation, the excitement you feel is simply ephemeral, and just like a caffeine pill, you lose your rush after awhile. Why these albums grab you so forcefully, who knows? It may be that it's so different from the band's previous works, or the songs are extremely catchy, either way, the novelty wears thin at some point. Perhaps you encounter a hangover period, and you're unable to listen to this album for awhile after your initial high. But, nonetheless, the caffeine pill is still a very good album, and even through a sober analysis, it stacks up quite well to the rest of the artist's discography.
Example: Kanye West- 808s and Heartbreak
3) The Ugly Duckling: This is one I'm sure you're all familiar with. As we all know, sometimes you'll hear an album for the first time, and you won't really like it. Much like The Caffeine Pill, the reasons why are a mystery, but in most instances, the sound on the album is just different. This is especially difficult when you go in for your first listen expecting more of the same signature sound from that band, only to be completely surprised by what you hear. Many of you will be turned off by this new sound, and will immediately write off the album as a failure. But, out of the blue, a song or two will from that album will come up on your shuffle a few weeks later, and all of a sudden it clicks, and you dive back in for a second and third listen. It is then that you finally begin to appreciate the album for what it is, a truly great piece of work. It's no longer the ugly duckling, it's matured into a majestic swan....no homo.
Example: Kings of Leon- Because of the Times
4) The Clunker: The name of this category pretty much explains it all. This is the ugly duckling that never develops, it just continues to look stupid and lame. Often times it will be from a band that you really like, and when you face the disappointment of hearing this album for the first time you'll say to itself, "that's ok, give it time, I'm sure it will grow on me..." Alas, it never does. You might be able to salvage one or two songs from the album for regular ipod play, but on the whole, you'll wish you could trade this album in for a cash credit to go towards a more listener-friendly album. Better luck next time.
Example: Cold War Kids- Loyalty to Loyalty
5) The Arc of the Covenant: The most destructive force ever known to man. Forget about growing on you, this album is so painfully awful that it will literally melt your face off. Worse yet, it's so bad that you will question why you ever listened to this band in the first place, and you'll find yourself unable to listen to their previous work ever again, let alone any of their future albums. The only thing to do with this album is to lock it up in a large wooden crate, and then hide it in a giant warehouse somewhere.
Example: Coldplay- X & Y (YOU HEARD ME!!)
As you can tell, time also factors in quite heavily to this rubric. How much time needs to pass by in order to know a clunker will not become an ugly duckling? That's up to you, but I say it's no more than 3-4 listens over a month's time. Also, as you can probably tell, the middle categories tend to be the most common, while Revelations and Arcs of the Covenant are extremely rare. As for debut albums, in which there's no other albums to compare them to, then it's anything goes...you either love it or you don't.
So there it is, my five simple, and very user friendly categories for evaluating a new album. Try it yourself sometime! Now, for my next post, I will put my system straight to the test, as I review the latest Arctic Monkey's album. Stay tuned...
-PG